Insights / Where a financial adviser actually adds value

Where a financial adviser actually adds value

A new study found advised retirees hold far more stocks than people investing on their own. What that does and doesn't mean, and why we think the value of advice is in the allocation and in staying invested, not in picking managers.

A recent research paper (opens in a new tab) from the National Bureau of Economic Research looked at thousands of retirees in Canada and found that those who worked with a financial adviser kept 30 to 40 percentage points more of their portfolios in stocks than retirees investing on their own or using target-date funds. The authors traced this mostly to advisers' own preferences: advisers tend to hold more stocks themselves, and clients who trust their adviser are more willing to follow suit.

It's a useful finding, but it doesn't mean more stocks is always better. Here is how we think about it.

More stocks isn't right for everyone

The study notes that many retirees have large, steady pension income, which can let them take more risk with the rest of their savings. That reasoning holds for some people and not for others.

When someone has a firm minimum they need to live on and no other way to earn income, we hold more in bonds and cash, because that person can't afford a large loss at the wrong time. The right mix depends on what your portfolio has to pay for, not on a rule of thumb or on what your adviser happens to like.

Think about bonds and cash in dollars, not just percentages

A common approach is to keep a fixed percentage in bonds. We often suggest looking at it as a dollar amount instead.

Say you need 20% in bonds on a $1 million portfolio. That's $200,000. If the portfolio grows to $1.5 million, do you still need 20%, which is now $300,000? Or does the $200,000 still cover what it was meant to cover? Sizing bonds and cash to what you actually need to fund is often clearer than chasing a percentage. When interest rates change, it's worth revisiting that dollar amount too.

Where advice tends to help

  • Staying invested. Every election, crisis or headline brings an urge to sell. A big part of our job is talking through those moments so a short-term reaction doesn't become a long-term mistake. If a change is rational and fits your plan, we're open to it. We can't promise good investments, but we can help you avoid bad decisions.
  • Putting idle cash to work. People investing on their own often keep extra cash "just in case." Having a plan for your reserve makes it easier to decide how much is enough and what the rest is for.
  • Allocation over stock picking. S&P Dow Jones Indices tracks how actively managed funds compare with their benchmarks in its SPIVA scorecard (opens in a new tab). As of June 30, 2026, about 90% of actively managed U.S. large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500 over 15 years, and about 93% over 20 years. That's one reason we focus on low-cost, diversified allocations instead of paying for manager selection.

The bottom line

In our view, the value an adviser adds is in getting the allocation right for your situation and helping you stick with it, not in picking managers or predicting markets. If you'd like a second opinion on your own mix, book a free intro call, or try our risk tolerance questionnaire to start the conversation.

General education, not personal advice. This article explains general rules as of November 16, 2026. Rules and figures change, and your situation is your own. Talk to a qualified adviser before acting. Sherman Financial, LLC is registered with the North Carolina Secretary of State Securities Division; registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. No investment result is guaranteed.

Book a free intro call (opens Google Calendar in a new tab)

Schedule a free intro call

One hour. No commitment. No pitch. Just a real conversation about your financial goals.

View available times (opens Google Calendar in a new tab)

Powered by Google Calendar · Meetings conducted via Google Meet · Prefer to call? (919) 923-2337

Free · 1 hour · By video or in person

Book a free call with us

Talk through your situation with one of our advisers. No commitment. No pitch. If we're a good fit, we'll give you a time estimate before any work begins.

See available times (opens Google Calendar in a new tab)

Prefer to call? (919) 923-2337